Thanks to all for your contributions !
Does anybody know if DVD-RAM's are made with
exactly the
same phase change material as DVD RW's ?
- or is the
BMC layer (Bismuth Coupling Material used for Maxell 5x certified) even of better quality
- and on top of that the
bonding better for DVD RAM's ...
I just report here the new climatic tests results (Stab. rating) which c't Magazine published in it's 20/2005 issue.
These tests were made on 2 rewritable DVD's
and the summary by MediumRare in this post:
http://www.cdrlabs.com/phpBB/viewtopic.php?t=13405&postdays=0&postorder=asc&&start=170
- Code: Select all
DVD-R 16x DVD-RW 6x DVD+RW 8x
Bound Taiyo Yuden Verbatim Ricoh
TYG03 MKM 01RW6X01 RICOHJPN W21(001)
AxialN [mu] 0.2 0.257 0.150 0.220
RadialN [nm] 25 18.9 33.0 16.0
RRO [mu] 70 20.9 43.8 46.3
Mech. Index/ Grade 84 / ++ 74 / + 69 / +
Writing quality 0 -- -
Clim. Stability ++ ++ ++
The comment of MediumRare:
« The rewritables do very well in the stability tests because
the phase change material used is more robust than the organic dyes used in write-once media.
In fact, the error rates for the Ricoh discs decreased after the heat and humidity treatment.
The RW's have excellent physical properties so that the writing problems (esp. Verbatim -RW) should decrease with better firmware
»