K-Probe reading with CD burnt on ASUS CRW 5232

[Arup]

Hi All,

The reason for my post is because I am not familiar with K-Probe and am hoping all veterans here will have a much better interpretation of this reading. This reading is possible due to the new K-Probe 2.22 ability to read through DVD-ROM(thanks to Karr Wong), I took these readings with my Liteon DVD 163D with the latest firmare. The CD used was burnt on my brand new ASUS CRW 5232 with latest 1.3 firmware on a Mitsubishi Super Azo 16x rated blank at 4x speed using EAC with burn offset correction. Seems like CDRInfo.com had a faulty ASUS CRW5232 on their test bed as the jitter and C1/C2 errors as well as pit land errors they got were far more than what I see. I wanted to buy Liteon only as my older Liteon 40x is still working fine but here in India, Liteon is virtually non-existent and there is no support even if you manage to find one. I have attached the PNG file from K-Probe and would appreciate any inputs. Even the Nero CD Speed latest version 3.10 yielded very low C1/C2 error count and no jitters whatsoever. Funnily this same drive was given superb ratings by Ian(9/10)CDR Labs and others.

TIA

K-Probe readings are:

C1 Max=26, Average=0.06, Total=256
C2 Max=70, Average=0.05, Total=196


[/img]

[MediumRare]

KProbe scans of CD's in a DVD-Rom drive are meaningless. The C1,C2 values are reported differently and are not a realistic measure of disc quality.

In my opinion, it was a positive change that KProbe2 (unlike KProbe 1) did not report these- it just causes confusion.

If you can't find a LiteOn in India, you may want to look for Sony drives- they're (usually) OEM LiteOns.

G

[Bhairav]

*snip*
[/img]

You can get the Lite-On 52327S in Mumbai for around 1800 rupees, while the Sony CRX225/230, 52327S OEMs, are around 1850-1900. I've had to RMA my 52327S once, got it returned in about 3 days, which I consider to be pretty fast.

[Arup]

thanks for the reply guys but what I would really like to know is that are these really bad readings or should I stick to the ASUS, I kinda like te build quality of the ASUS over others in the market.

[Bhairav]

thanks for the reply guys but what I would really like to know is that are these really bad readings or should I stick to the ASUS, I kinda like te build quality of the ASUS over others in the market.

Decent readings, but the Asus is not optimised to work with KProbe, so I would take those results with a grain of salt. Nero CDSpeed ScanDisc, are all blocks green?If so, you have nothing to worry about.

[Arup]

I burnt the CD with my ASUS and took the measurments with my Liteon 163D DVD player which is compatible with K-Probe latest version.