I think it is the pink on the left one and the slim ankles on the right one that make them look a bit less than manly.
Just the point, Jamie, I do have SLIM anles, that's why I can only buy custom made boots from places like that.
If one disregards the "look", check the sizes. They don't make women's boots in 13EEEE.
For a better comparison, very little - it's mainly sizing, between men's and women's boots, scroll here
I have five pair on the list above, but if I want to have any credibility with BuudhaTB and his 569 pairs of Nikes, I've got to get down to Nogales for that slim-ankled blue pair in the first link.