BenQ 1620 ?
any other candidates ?
voice your opinion!

|
||||||||
|
Ian wrote:The original question pertained to quality testing.. not which one gives the best quality.
dolphinius_rex wrote:
It's a fast drive, with excellent burn quality, completely unrivaled firmware support that no other competing company even comes CLOSE to, and the ability to test your media with DVDInfoPro or Nero CD/DVD Speed when needed.
dodecahedron wrote:hmm...too bad, i was hoping for a more active discussion on this subject
dodecahedron wrote:and if i were to ask you to choose between the BenQ DW1620 and the Lite-On 1633S ? (are you at all familiar with this Lite-On?)
Halc wrote:Dodecahedron,
you are asking for the impossible.
However, if you only want one drive, then I suggest:
Plextor PX-716A, BECAUSE it can plot jitter data (i.e. lower level signal measurement than just causal errors)
OR
BenQ DW1620, because it can also (to a more limited degree) plot data-to-clock jitter data.
There is no hope for you in finding a single drive that is reliable for testing.
Drives can only be considered reliable testers for themselves. That is, if you test in Unit A from maker B, using model C, then the test will be reliable for that particular unit.
That's all there is to it.
dodecahedron wrote:so in this sense at least the BenQ is better then the Lite-On.
mmm
so maybe i should've asked:
if i were to ask you to choose between the BenQ DW1620 and the Plextor PX-712A ?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests
All Content is Copyright (c) 2001-2025 CDRLabs Inc. |